Keep Your Church Out of Court

Disclaimer: This notebook and seminar does NOT constitute legal advice.

Our Goal for “Keep Your Church Out of Court”:

  • Provide an overview of important legal issues and litigation risks.
  • Summarize the top 5 reasons churches go to court.
  • Consider 5 key areas for mitigating lawsuit risk.
  • Provide resources for more information.

“Keep Your Church Out of Court” presents a summary of legal issues with a view towards real-world application. The seminar content is:

  • Organized by key areas of law/litigation
  • Outlined in the Section 1 pullout – Seminar Outline
  • Presented as a two-hour overview of general church legal issues

Administration and Law – Recognize that administration exists to facilitate:

  • Ministry
  • Gospel Impact
  • The Great Commission

The application of the law is just another tool to facilitate (or impede) effective ministry.

Section 1 – Legal Summary

Seminar Outline* (4 pages)

Church Legal Matters Overview” by Michael Best* (7 pages)

  • Corporate (Transactions & Governance)
    • 501(c)(3) Subsidiaries – Consider subsidiary governance, boards, property and tax IDs.
    • Corporate Governance Structure – See Section 7
      • How are important decisions made?
      • Does this mirror the organization’s constitution and bylaws?
      • Bylaw-defined roles for Lead Pastor, Church Staff, Deacons, Committees and Trustees should be found here.
      • Follow your governing documents. Not following these documents may constitute grounds for litigation.
    • Marriage/Gender Identity Views – See Section 6
      • Doctrinal Statements are foundational, but may not be enough.
      • Answer the questions: Who can be married at my church?
        What kinds of marriages may pastors at my church officiate?
      • Marriage Definition
      • Other Factors – Counseling, Covenant Marriage
    • Waivers of Liability – See Section 4
      • It’s important to recognize that lawsuits can occur at any time and for any reason.
      • Waivers simply mitigate risk and deter potential lawsuits.
    • Membership – See Section 7
      • Because church membership typically confers special privileges, it is an important milestone.
      • In most churches, members can: Serve in leadership, serve on committees, become a deacon, have a marriage ceremony, vote on church business, etc.
      • Answer the question: Who can become a member?
      • Define a Church Discipline Process in your bylaws.
  • Commercial Real Estate
    • Real Estate Transactions
    • Land Use and Zoning
  • Intellectual Property
    • Licensing (CCLI/CVLI)
    • Streaming and Social Media Content
    • Data Privacy and Data Breaches
  • Employment Law
  • Other General Legal Issues
    • Financial Policy
    • Church Discipline
    • Security and Safety

Section 2 – Reasons Churches Go to Court

The Top 5 Reasons Churches and Religious Organizations Go to Court” Excerpt by Matthew Branaugh and Church Law & Tax* (7 pages)
Current as of July 7, 2023 | Full Presentation from Church Law & Tax

  1. The Sexual Abuse of a Minor – See Section 3
    • Abuse Prevention Plans – Churches have an obligation to address the opportunities and potential for the abuse of children with a determined, intentional preparedness effort. Work to create an environment where it is virtually impossible for sexual abuse to occur on church property during church ministries and events.
  2. Property Disputes
    • Multiple Tracts – As churches grow, it’s possible that additional tracts of real estate were purchased for facility and parking lot expansion. This is especially true when adjacent homes and real estate is purchased over a long period of time. Ensure good recordkeeping for church real estate transactions.
    • Check Tax Records for Accuracy – Multiple tracts create an opportunity for inaccurate reporting and recording. Ensure that your church is accurately reflected as the owner for each tract in your portfolio.
    • Governing Documents – Ensure that property transactions are executed by church officers specified by your organization’s governing documents.
  3. Personal Injury – See Section 4
    • Lawsuits – Personal Injury Lawsuits occur regularly in personal, private business and church settings. Mitigate your risk wherever possible, protect your church with appropriate levels of liability insurance, and be prepared for Personal Injury Lawsuits.
    • Risk Management and Mitigation – Most insurance companies provide risk assessments and recommendations for their policyholders. Regular inspections and walkarounds often yield a list of action items to mitigate risks and liability exposure.
  4. Zoning – Some local governments have made it more difficult for churches to operate and own property. Federal law explicitly protects churches and other religious institutions and individuals from unduly burdensome or discriminatory land use and zoning regulations. After learning that local land use and zoning regulations often placed burdens on religious congregations’ ability to practice their faith in violation of the U.S. Constitution, Congress enacted the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act of 2000 (RLUIPA). See “What Churches Need to Know About Local Zoning and Land Use Laws” by Church Law Center.
  5. Insurance Coverage Disputes – See Section 5
    • Property
    • Liability
    • Auto/Vehicles
    • Umbrella
    • Workers’ Compensation

Section 3 – Abuse Prevention

Abuse Prevention Summary* (5 pages)

  • Mandated Reporters – Every state in the U.S. has laws identifying individuals who are mandated reporters, typically professionals who have regular contact with children or vulnerable adults. These laws are designed to ensure that suspected cases of abuse or neglect are reported to the appropriate authorities for investigation and intervention.
  • General Abuse Prevention Guidelines – Effective Abuse Prevention Plans include background checks, adequate screening, automatic exclusions for ineligible workers, child protection policies, security procedures, and prompt incident reporting.
  • 5-5-5 Method (also known as “Essentials Curriculum”) – “The Essentials: Sexual Abuse Prevention and Response Training” curriculum is provided without charge by the Southern Baptist Convention as a resource for small and medium-sized churches. It leads churches to establish or evaluate an abuse prevention and response plan.

Mandated Reporters of Child Abuse and Neglect” by Louisiana DCFS* (2 pages)

Child Protection Policies & Volunteer Screening

  • Child Protection Policy/Reporting Process* (5 pages) – Every church should have a Child Protection Policy with robust abuse prevention rules and a clear reporting process for any suspected abuse or inappropriate volunteer behavior.
  • Kids Ministry Leader Application* (3 pages) – Volunteers should be thoroughly vetted with background checks, references, staff leader observation and personal interviews. Any prospective volunteer with preschoolers, children or students should be considered for service only after a defined waiting period (usually six months to one year).
  • Houston’s First Baptist Church Protection Policy* (14 pages)

Additional Abuse Prevention Exhibits & Resources

  • Accident Report* (1 page) – File an Accident Report to document all injuries, accidents or mishaps that occur at any church facility or event (onsite or offsite), as well as incidents involving any church-sponsored transportation.
  • Summer Camps/Trips Safety E-mail* (2 pages) – Recognize special safety considerations for offsite travel, camps and other events. Anticipate hot (or cold) weather contingencies and brief leaders and volunteers on safety protocols for medical emergencies and other concerns.
  • Sex Offender Policy & Covenant* (4 pages) – For churches and ministries with resources to manage identified sex offenders in public settings and facilitate ministry to this challenging group, create a thorough policy and covenant to establish clear guardrails and expectations. A well-staffed Safety and Security Team is a likely pre-requisite for any ministry of this kind.

Section 4 – Liability & Personal Injury Lawsuits

Lawsuits & Legal Maneuvers

  • Accidents, mishaps and injuries on church property can result in personal injury lawsuits.
  • What to Do When an Accident Occurs:
    • Administer first aid, call 9-1-1 and ensure the injured party receives quality care.
    • Ensure the comfort of the injured party and communicate the church’s desire to care for personal, spiritual and physical needs.
    • File a MedPay claim with the church’s insurance company. MedPay helps pay medical expenses for an injured party after an accident, regardless of fault. Provide claim information to the injured party.
    • Communicate regularly with the injured party to convey the church’s goodwill and ensure prompt resolution of their claim.
    • Work in good faith for the injured party’s good health and personal restoration. Mediate with your insurance company as necessary to expedite the claim process.
  • What Happens When You Get Sued?
    • Demand Letters – A Demand Letter is official notice that states the harm suffered by the sender, requests relief, and may threaten legal action. Demand Letters may include a demand for compensation. Understand that an attorney’s Demand Letter is not legal action, although the threat of legal action may be present.
    • Legal Action – 
    • Interrogatories –
    • Internal Documents and Communication –
    • Intimidation Tactics –
  • Insurance Company’s Role
    • 3-8-23 Claim #000-01-258011 E-mail* (3 pages)
  • Settlements

Waivers of Liability & Incident Documentation

  • Waiver of Liability & Medical Release – Minor* (2 pages) – Any event, activity, camp or transportation event with minors requires a Waiver of Liability and Medical Release. Medical Releases should be accessible to leaders during all phases of an event with extended travel time. Since medical events can occur at any time, this includes bus transportation, hotel stays and summer camps.
  • Waiver of Liability & Medical Release – Adult* (2 pages) – Require Waivers of Liability for any adult event or activity involving church-sponsored transportation or extended travel time away (hotel stays, bus travel, etc.). Adult waivers are especially important for senior adult activities, where trip hazards in new environments increase your liability exposure.
  • Incident Report* (1 page) – Incident Reports record unusual events that may not qualify as an accident or mishap. This could be minor altercations, verbal conflict with church leaders, argumentative behavior, abusive conduct or language, and other events above the reporting threshold. When in doubt about whether to record a borderline incident, encourage leaders to do so as a precaution.

Risk Assessment & Management

Section 5 – Insurance Coverage Disputes

  • 2023 Insurance Issues Report* (3 pages)
    • Louisiana Insurance Climate
    • Non-Renewals
    • Wind/Hail Exclusions and Disputes
    • Negotiation
  • Policyholders Release* (1 page)

Section 6 – Facilities, Weddings & Funerals

Policy Issues Summary* (4 pages)

  • Abuse Prevention Policy
  • Minor Participation Policy
  • Social Media Policy
  • Staff Team Policies
  • ADA Compliance

Facility Use Policy* (4 pages)

Weddings

Funerals

  • Potential Area of Future Litigation
  • Funeral Policy Development
    • Facility Use Policy
    • How Inclusive Will the Church Be?
    • Is there a Membership Requirement?
    • What Content Is Permissible?
    • Who Officiates?

Section 7 – Constitution/Bylaws & Administration

Church Bylaws Summary* (3 pages)

Admin & Tax Forms Summary* (3 pages)

Forms & Documents Summary* (2 pages)

Section 8 – Keeping Your Church Out of Court

Keeping Your Church Out of Court, 4th Edition” by Texas Baptists* (146 pages)

  1. Church Organization and Operation
  2. Church Liability for Personal Injury and Property Damage Claims
  3. Decision Makers: Liability and Protection
  4. Employment Law
  5. Taxes and Governmental Compliance
  6. Intellectual Property

*  Document Attached

   Seminar Outline

   Seminar Slide Deck

   Seminar Content

   Church Law & Tax

   Alliance Defending Freedom

   Michael Best

Additional Resources 

   Forms & Documents

   Admin & Tax Forms

   Policy Issues

   Abuse Prevention

   Church Bylaws